FinanceDalal Street Investment Journal
Ather Energy Has Returned 266% in One Year. ROE Is -33%. ROCE Is -20%. Free Cash Flow Is Negative. So What Is the Market Actually Buying?

in5points
Ather Energy returned 266% in one year despite ROE of -33%, ROCE of -20%, and negative free cash flow.
Investors are valuing Ather on future scale, not current profitability, betting it becomes a dominant electric two-wheeler platform in India.
Ather's market share in India's electric two-wheeler segment rose from 7.6% in Q1 FY25 to 18.6% in Q4 FY26.
India's electric two-wheeler penetration was only 6.5% in FY26, but monthly penetration crossed 10% by June 2026, indicating early-stage transition.
Ola Electric's retail sales declined 52.28% in FY26, shifting market leadership away from its former top position.